Review · ST AUGUSTINE
St Augustine: OId Jail After Dark Paranormal Investigation
St. Augustine’s Old Jail gets interesting when the doors close and the ordinary tour ends. Built as a place of punishment and shut in 1953 after years of cruel conditions, it carries stories of eight hangings and other unnatural deaths. I like the chance to handle the investigation equipment yourself, rather than simply watch a guide perform a staged ghost show.
I also like the small group limit of eight, which gives you more time to ask questions and use the tools. Guides including Fran and Jaciel are praised for their clear instruction and open approach. The drawback is the very late start, usually just before midnight, and the $106 price may feel high if you want only a quick haunted-house visit.
Key points
- You investigate instead of just listening: Use traditional and modern ghost-hunting devices with guidance from the staff.
- The Old Jail has a grim past: Eight hangings and years of harsh conditions give the setting more weight than a simple spooky attraction.
- Groups stay very small: A maximum of eight people makes it easier to ask questions and take part.
- The tour runs late: Expect to meet at the Old Jail shortly before midnight.
- Your phone can help: Use its camera and audio recorder to look for photos and possible electronic voice phenomena.
- You get help sorting findings: Guides discuss ordinary explanations after the investigation ends.
Inside St. Augustine’s Old Jail after midnight

The Old Jail is not just a dark building dressed up for Halloween. It operated as a real jail until 1953, when its poor conditions and cruel treatment of prisoners helped bring about its closure. Eight people were hanged there, and the site is connected with other deaths that have fed its long ghost lore.
That background matters. You are not entering a generic haunted attraction with actors waiting around a corner. You are entering a former jail, a place built around confinement, punishment, and fear. Even if you remain doubtful about ghosts, the building’s past gives the investigation a serious subject.
The meeting point is the entrance to the Old Jail. The investigation lasts 150 minutes, and departures take place just before midnight. That timing gives the night a different feel from a standard daytime tour, but it also means you should plan your evening around a late finish.
I would not book this as a casual add-on between dinner and an early morning outing. The late hour is part of the appeal, yet it can be tiring. Children under 13 cannot take part, and the activity is offered in English.
More Ghost Hunts in St Augustine
- Medieval Torture Museum with Ghost Hunting and Tiny Art Gallery
★ 5.0 · 2,011 reviews - Haunted Saint Augustine A Paranormal Investigation
★ 5.0 · 67 reviews - St.Augustine: Torture Museum, Ghost Hunt, & Tiny Art Tickets
★ 4.5 · 59 reviews
Your first lesson in paranormal investigation

Before you begin looking for evidence, the guides explain how they work. You learn techniques intended to prepare you for odd sounds, unusual readings, and other phenomena that may occur inside the jail.
This introduction is important because it sets a better tone than simply declaring every creak to be a ghost. A good investigation needs patience and a willingness to question what you notice. The guides help you understand the equipment, then later help you consider logical explanations for anything unusual.
Fran is specifically praised for his instruction and for explaining both the building and the investigation process. Jaciel is also named as a particularly warm and capable guide. Staff members may vary, but the strongest part of the setup is the direct contact with people who know how to run the investigation.
You should take part from the start. Ask questions, listen carefully, and keep track of what you notice. One useful point from the evening is that you are encouraged to interact rather than stand silently in the background. If you feel awkward asking questions aloud, you may miss much of what makes the activity different from a normal haunted-history tour.
Using ghost-hunting equipment yourself

Each person receives training in an array of traditional and state-of-the-art ghost-hunting equipment. The supplied information does not name every device, so you should not arrive expecting a specific model or a fixed list of gadgets. The clear promise is hands-on use, with guides showing you how to operate the tools.
That hands-on element gives the $106 price more purpose. You are paying for more than access to the building. You are also receiving instruction, use of the equipment, and time to test what you notice with a small group and professional guidance.
Bring your own devices if you have them. The activity specifically allows personal ghost-hunting equipment from home. Your mobile phone is useful even if you own nothing else. Its camera can record images, while its audio recorder may capture possible EVP, or electronic voice phenomena.
Use your phone thoughtfully. Recordings are easier to assess if you remember where you were standing and what was happening at the time. A loud air conditioner, a nearby voice, or a bump against the phone can create strange results. The guides’ help at the end is valuable because it gives you a chance to question your own evidence instead of accepting every odd sound as proof.
Moving through the jail in a group of eight

The group limit is one of the best practical features. With no more than eight participants, you should have room to handle the equipment and ask the guides questions. A crowded room can make it hard to hear a faint sound or know who moved near a device. A smaller party reduces some of that confusion.
The group size can also change the feel of the night. One person described having the building almost to themselves when only a very small party arrived. That is not something you can count on, but it shows why a quiet date or a low-demand evening may produce a more private setting.
You will be expected to participate. Ask the spirits questions if that is comfortable for you, and stay attentive when the group is testing a room or listening for a response. If you prefer a passive tour, this may feel like work rather than entertainment.
The Old Jail itself supplies the atmosphere. You have the old cells, the former confinement spaces, and the knowledge that the building was once an active jail. The information provided does not promise access to every room or describe a fixed route, so the exact movement through the building can depend on the guides and the evening’s plan.
More Haunted Prison Tours in St Augustine:
- Charleston Haunted Jail Night-Time Walking Tour with Admission to Old City Jail
★ 4.5 · 570 reviews - Adelaide: Ghosts, Dark Secrets and Paranormal Hunt Gaol Tour
★ 3.9 · 93 reviews - Adelaide Gaol Ghost Tour and Paranormal Investigation
★ 4.0 · 66 reviews - Shrewsbury Prison Ghost Tour
★ 4.8 · 29 reviews
Separating strange results from ordinary causes

The most sensible part of the format comes after the investigation. The guides help you rule out logical explanations from your findings and discuss what may have caused unusual sounds, readings, or sensations.
That step helps keep the evening balanced. Paranormal activity is a matter of personal belief, and a recording or unexplained noise does not automatically settle the question. A guide who encourages you to examine possible causes gives you a more useful way to think about the night.
Several people have described hearing voices, receiving relevant responses, or finding unexplained activity in their recordings. Those reports are part of the fun, but you should keep your own standards. A response that sounds clear in the moment may seem less certain later. That is why saving your recordings and checking them afterward can be worthwhile.
The activity suits both believers and skeptics. One skeptical participant went in doubtful while family members were already interested in ghosts, then found the history and staff made the evening enjoyable even without a change of belief. That is a good way to approach it. You do not need to decide in advance that ghosts are real, and you do not need to pretend that every result is meaningless.
What the $106 price gets you

At $106 per person, this is not a budget attraction. The cost makes the most sense if you value the full 2.5-hour format, expert instruction, equipment use, and a group capped at eight. You are paying for a guided investigation inside a historic jail, not simply a short walk through dark rooms.
The price is harder to justify if you mainly want local history or a quick introduction to St. Augustine’s haunted stories. A regular historical visit may suit you better if you do not want to operate equipment or stay out until midnight.
I see the value in the format for people who already enjoy paranormal investigations. You get time to test devices, ask questions, and review what happened with the guides. Repeat visitors also have a reason to return, since each investigation can unfold differently and the staff may remember you. One couple returns to St. Augustine often and books the investigation each time.
There is also value for a mixed group. A believer can enjoy the tools and possible responses, while a skeptic can focus on the jail’s past and the process of testing evidence. The activity does not require you to accept one explanation.
Timing, comfort, and small practical details
Plan to meet at the Old Jail shortly before midnight. Check the starting time when you book, since the exact departure time is not fixed in the information provided. Give yourself enough time to reach the entrance without rushing.
There are no restrooms inside the jail. The staff takes the group to a restroom before the investigation begins, and you can leave with a guide if you need to go during the activity. That is a small detail, but it matters during a 150-minute late-night outing.
The activity is in English, and children under 13 are not permitted. The small group format may be a good fit for couples, friends, and families with older teenagers, as long as everyone is willing to participate and stay up late.
Free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the activity for a full refund. You can also reserve now and pay later, which helps if your St. Augustine plans are still shifting.
Who will enjoy this most

I would choose this for someone who wants more than a ghost story. You should enjoy asking questions, trying equipment, and sitting with uncertainty. The best attitude is curious but not gullible.
It is especially suited to:
- People who already follow paranormal investigations
- Skeptics who enjoy testing claims
- Couples looking for a late-night activity
- Repeat visitors to St. Augustine who want something different
- Small groups who prefer direct contact with guides
- History fans who can appreciate the jail’s difficult past
I would skip it if you dislike late nights, do not want to participate, or expect guaranteed proof of ghosts. The activity offers tools and instruction, not a promise that a spirit will appear or answer every question.
Should you book the Old Jail investigation?

Book it if you want a hands-on night inside one of St. Augustine’s most talked-about historic buildings. The small group, practical instruction, and post-investigation discussion give the activity more substance than a standard haunted tour. Fran, Jaciel, and other guides appear to be a major part of the value, especially if you want help understanding the equipment and questioning your results.
Think twice if $106 feels steep or if you need an earlier evening. The late departure and lack of restrooms inside the jail require a little planning. My advice is to bring your phone, arrive ready to participate, and keep an open but critical mind. You may leave with an intriguing recording, a better sense of how paranormal investigations work, or simply a memorable look at a grim part of St. Augustine’s past.
FAQ

How long does the Old Jail paranormal investigation last?
The investigation lasts 150 minutes, or 2.5 hours.
When does the tour begin?
Tours depart just before midnight. Check availability for the exact starting time.
Where do I meet the guides?
Meet the guides at the entrance to the Old Jail.
How many people can join each investigation?
The group is limited to a maximum of eight participants.
Is the activity suitable for children?
No. Children under 13 are not permitted.
Can I bring my own ghost-hunting equipment?
Yes. You may bring ghost-hunting devices from home. The activity also provides training and use of traditional and state-of-the-art equipment.
Can I cancel for a refund?
Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. Reserve now and pay later is also available.
Freshly reviewed haunts around St Augustine
- St Augustine: Riding with the Ghosts Golf Cart Tour★ 4.6 · 34 reviews
- St. Augustine: Haunted Pub Crawl★ 3.9 · 38 reviews
- St. Augustine: Haunted Pub Crawl Walking Tour with a Guide★ 4.6 · 10 reviews
- St. Augustine: Devil’s Hour Paranormal Investigation Tour★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- St. Augustine: Dixie House Paranormal Investigation★ 5.0 · 7 reviews
- St. Augustine: Evening Paranormal Investigation Tour★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
- St. Augustine: Adults-Only Walking Ghost Tour★ 4.2 · 7 reviews
- St. Augustine: Dead Walk Ghost Tour★ 3.7 · 4 reviews
St Augustine Ghost Tours, compared.

St. Augustine Ghost Tour: A Ghostly Encounter
Read our review →
Ghost Tour of St. Augustine: The Original Haunted History Tour
Read our review →
St. Augustine: Ghosts and Gravestones Old Town Trolley Tour
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in





