Review · MILWAUKEE
Shakers Ghost Tour 2.0
Shakers Cigar Bar is not a polished haunted attraction. It is an old Milwaukee bar with a rough past, and the tour takes you through the basement, second floor, and third floor while telling stories about a cemetery, speakeasy, and brothel. The building itself does much of the work.
I like the small group of no more than 15 people, which gives you room to ask questions and use the dowsing rods without fighting through a crowd. I also like that the tour is fully indoors and includes a cocktail. The main caution is that the experience depends heavily on your guide, and one poorly prepared substitute guide can change the whole evening.
- The 10 p.m. start gives this tour the right spooky mood, but you should arrive at least 20 minutes early.
- The basement, second floor, and third floor provide more than a quick look around the bar.
- Dowsing rods and an included cocktail make the experience hands-on rather than a simple storytelling session.
- Guide quality matters, with Jennifer, Joe, CJ, Amanda, Ciji, and Kiersten earning especially strong praise.
- The $46.60 price is fair if you value the history, guided access, and interactive elements, but less so if you want guaranteed paranormal activity.
- The tour ends where it begins, at Shakers Cigar Bar on South 2nd Street.
Why Shakers Cigar Bar makes a convincing setting

The appeal here begins with the building. Shakers Cigar Bar has been associated with several very different chapters of Milwaukee’s past, including a cemetery, a speakeasy, and a brothel. That is a far more interesting foundation than a generic haunted-house script.
You are not simply walking through a dark room while a guide points out staged effects. The tour uses the building’s past as its main material. The stories are described as gritty and sometimes unpleasant, so I would not choose this outing if you want a light, family-style ghost tale.
The bar has also been voted one of the five most haunted bars in the nation. That claim is part of the atmosphere, not proof that you will see a spirit. The best way to approach it is with curiosity. You can enjoy the old building and local stories even if nothing supernatural happens.
That balance matters. One person may come away convinced the place has an unusual energy. Another may enjoy the history, take some photographs, and leave without seeing anything strange. Both are reasonable outcomes for this sort of night tour.
What the 90-minute route includes

The published duration is about 90 minutes, and the tour takes place indoors. A separate booking detail displays four hours, which conflicts with the stated 90-minute schedule. I would treat 90 minutes as the useful planning figure and confirm the timing when you book if your evening is tightly scheduled.
The route includes the basement, second floor, and third floor. That variety gives the tour a sense of movement and lets you see more of the historic building than you would during a regular drink at the bar.
Other ghost walks and hunts we rate around the USA
- New Orleans Premier Ghost, Voodoo and Vampire Walking Tour
★ 4.5 · 12,856 reviews - Chicago: Gangsters and Ghosts Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 7,155 reviews - Adults-Only New Orleans Ghost, Crime, Voodoo, and Vampire Tour
★ 5.0 · 6,545 reviews
The basement
The basement is an important part of the experience because it adds a darker, more enclosed setting to the stories. It is also one of the areas specifically mentioned by people who enjoyed the tour. You might spend time hearing about the building’s earlier uses and testing the rods in this part of the property.
Basements can be challenging for anyone who dislikes confined or shadowy spaces. The supplied information does not list detailed accessibility conditions, so you should contact the provider if stairs or uneven areas are a concern.
The second and third floors
The upper floors help show that Shakers is more than a bar with a ghost story attached. Moving through several levels gives the guide room to connect different tales to different parts of the building.
The upper-floor visits are also useful for photographs. One particularly positive account mentioned getting good pictures while exploring the building and using the dowsing rods. You should still treat photography as part of the fun, not as a promise that every image will contain something unexplained.
Dowsing rods make the tour interactive
The most distinctive activity is the chance to use divination, or dowsing, rods. Instead of only listening to the guide, you take part in a simple paranormal investigation and see how the rods respond.
This helps the tour work for people who are not committed believers. You can handle the equipment, compare what happens, and make up your own mind. The process also gives the group something to do during quieter moments, rather than asking everyone to stand silently in a dark room.
Some people may feel a strong presence or unusual energy. Others may get no response at all. One person specifically noted that no ghost appeared, but still found the building and rods fascinating. That is the right expectation: the rods are an interactive tool, not a guarantee of contact.
An included cocktail adds another unusual touch. You can sip a drink while taking part in the experience, which makes the evening feel more like a bar-based night out than a formal museum tour. The supplied information does not specify the cocktail, so do not plan around a particular drink.
Same old streets, another story to hear:
- Salem’s Best Ghost Tour
★ 4.5 · 4,186 reviews - Haunted Evening Horse and Carriage Tour of Charleston
★ 4.5 · 3,678 reviews - New Orleans Adults-Only Ghost, Voodoo and Vampire Tour
★ 5.0 · 3,291 reviews - Savannah History and Haunts Candlelit Ghost Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 3,235 reviews
The guide can make or break the evening

The strongest praise centers on the guides. Jennifer was described as excellent after leading a group through the basement and upper floors. Joe kept the tour fun and stayed afterward to answer additional questions. Amanda was praised for being informative and active during the spirit work.
CJ received credit for making the indoor activity interesting and encouraging participation. Ciji was described as patient, willing to share stories, and happy to encourage photographs. Kiersten was praised for handling a disruptive person while keeping the experience enjoyable.
Those details tell you what to look for in a good guide: clear storytelling, patience, willingness to answer questions, and enough energy to keep a small group involved. The limited group size should make those qualities easier to notice because you are not lost among dozens of people.
There is one clear warning. A substitute guide once received a very poor assessment for lacking preparation. The provider explained that the person had returned temporarily while new summer staff were being trained and was out of practice. That does not mean every replacement guide will be weak, but it confirms that the quality is not completely uniform.
I would book this with an open mind and remember that the guide is a major part of the value. If you enjoy asking questions, do so. One guide stayed after the formal tour to answer more, which is a good sign for visitors who want more than a memorized script.
Why the small group matters
The maximum group size is 15 people. That is large enough to create a little shared tension in the dark, but small enough for you to hear the guide and handle the rods.
A small group also gives you a better chance to ask about local history. The tour is not limited to ghost claims. It covers the area’s past and the building’s unusual uses, so questions about Milwaukee and the bar can add real value.
There is a practical tradeoff. If the group contains one disruptive person, the mood can suffer. Kiersten was specifically praised for managing that sort of problem, but no guide can fully control every participant. The small format usually helps, since the guide can address issues more directly.
Is $46.60 a fair price?
At $46.60 per person, this is not a bargain bar crawl. You are paying for a guided visit to several parts of the building, a roughly 90-minute program, the interactive dowsing-rod activity, and an included cocktail.
I think the price makes sense if you are already interested in haunted places, Milwaukee history, or unusual evening activities. The indoor setting is also useful on a rainy or cold night, and the tour does not depend on good weather.
The value is weaker if you expect a dramatic paranormal event. No tour can promise that a spirit will appear, and the experience has to be judged by the setting, stories, guide, and participation. If you would be disappointed by an evening with no supernatural sign, $46.60 may feel steep.
The strongest value comes from combining the tour with time at the bar, though the provided details do not specify how long you may stay before or after the program. Plan on the tour itself lasting about 90 minutes and regard the drink as part of the experience, not as the main reason to book.
Timing, meeting point, and planning tips
The tour starts at 10 p.m. at Shakers Cigar Bar, 422 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53204. The activity ends back at the same location, so you do not need to arrange a second pickup point.
Arrive at least 20 minutes before the start. That means aiming for about 9:40 p.m., not walking in at 10 p.m. with your coat still on and your phone searching for the address. The bar is described as easy to find and near public transportation.
The mobile ticket is convenient. Keep the confirmation available on your phone, since confirmation is issued at booking. The group limit is 15, and the tour is commonly booked about six days ahead, so last-minute availability is not something I would count on for a particular date.
The activity is listed as suitable for most people, but detailed accessibility information is not provided. If you need specific help with stairs, floors, or the building layout, ask Shakers Cigar Bar before purchasing.
Also note the firm cancellation rule. The experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason. If your plans are uncertain, wait until you are confident about the date.
Who will enjoy this most

I would recommend Shakers Ghost Tour 2.0 to you if you like:
- Old buildings with unpleasant or unusual backstories
- Local history presented in a relaxed bar setting
- Small-group activities where you can ask questions
- Hands-on paranormal tools rather than a simple walking lecture
- Indoor evening plans
- A little theatrical tension without needing a full haunted-house production
It also suits couples and friends looking for something different after dark. The cocktail and compact duration make it easy to fit into a night out, though the 10 p.m. start means it is not an early-evening activity.
You do not need to believe in ghosts to enjoy it. The building’s former cemetery, speakeasy, and brothel connections give the tour a historical angle, and several people have found the experience worthwhile even without seeing a spirit.
I would be more cautious if you dislike disturbing stories, cramped or dark areas, stairs, or guided activities built around paranormal claims. The tales are not described as pretty, and the tone is meant to be uneasy rather than gentle.
Should you book Shakers Ghost Tour 2.0?

Book it if you want a short, indoor, interactive Milwaukee night out built around a genuinely unusual building. The basement and upper floors, dowsing rods, cocktail, and small group give you more to do than simply listen to ghost stories at a bar.
Skip it if you need a polished, perfectly consistent production or a guaranteed supernatural encounter. Guide quality can vary, and the experience works best when you treat the ghost element as a possibility while appreciating the building and its hard-edged past.
For the best chance at a good evening, arrive early, keep your mobile ticket ready, bring questions, and choose a date you can definitely keep. At $46.60, it is a fair splurge for curious visitors who enjoy history with a chill down the spine.
FAQ
Where does Shakers Ghost Tour 2.0 begin?
It begins at Shakers Cigar Bar, 422 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204, USA.
What time does the tour start?
The listed start time is 10 p.m.
How early should I arrive?
You should arrive at least 20 minutes before the tour begins.
How long does the tour last?
The stated duration is approximately 90 minutes. One booking detail lists four hours, so you should confirm the timing if your schedule is tight.
Where does the tour end?
The activity ends back at Shakers Cigar Bar, the same place where it begins.
How many people can join the tour?
The maximum group size is 15 people.
Is the tour indoors?
Yes. The tour is described as completely indoors and includes the basement, second floor, and third floor.
Are dowsing rods included?
Yes. You can use divination, or dowsing, rods during the experience.
Is a drink included?
Yes. The experience includes a cocktail, though the specific type is not provided.
Can I cancel or change my booking?
No. The experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason.
Freshly reviewed haunts around the USA
- New Orleans French Quarter Dark History, Haunts, and Laughs Tour★ 5.0 · 30 reviews
- New Orleans’ Finest Haunted Pub Tour★ 4.5 · 38 reviews
- Cheers New Orleans! Cocktails, History, Voodoo & Paranormal Tour★ 4.0 · 4 reviews
- Haunted Drunken History Tour from New Orleans★ 5.0 · 135 reviews
- The Original Asbury Park Ghost Tour★ 4.5 · 29 reviews
- Adults-Only True Crime, Mafia, Dark History Tour★ 5.0 · 22 reviews
- Destrehan Plantation Haunted Night Tour★ 4.5 · 100 reviews
- New Haven’s Ghost Walk★ 3.5 · 69 reviews
Milwaukee Ghost Tours, compared.

The Ghosts of Milwaukee & the Haunted Third Ward: Private Tour
Read our review →
Milwaukee Downtown Ghost Tour – The Shadow of City Hall
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in





