Review · ITALY
Florence Crimes, Murders & Ghosts Walking Tour with Tastings
Florence’s beauty can feel almost too polished. This walking tour rubs away the shine and shows you the city of executions, prisons, revenge, occult legends, and unsolved murder. You begin at Piazza della Signoria, where power once played out in public and Girolamo Savonarola met his end.
I like the way the tour connects grim stories to real streets, rather than treating Florence as a backdrop. I also like the food breaks: a glass of Tuscan wine with cold cuts near the Duomo, followed by cantucci and Vin Santo. The main caution is simple: the tour is more intriguing than terrifying. If you want a full-on ghost scare, the stories may feel too historical and not quite spooky enough.
Key points to know
- Savonarola’s execution site: Begin in Piazza della Signoria, where Florence’s political and religious battles turned deadly.
- The Monster of Florence: Hear about the still-unsolved 1984 murder case that gives the tour its modern true-crime edge.
- Food with the folklore: Stop for Tuscan wine, prosciutto, traditional specialties, and vegetarian options near the Duomo.
- The Stinche prison: Learn how Florence used public justice, torture, and ritual to control its population.
- Cantucci and Vin Santo: Finish at a historic cernacchio with one of Tuscany’s classic sweet pairings.
- Small-group feel: The experience has been especially praised for warm guides, personal attention, and useful local tips.
Florence after dark, without waiting for night

This is a city walking tour with a crime-story frame. You do not spend the whole time hearing about ghosts, and you do not visit a museum devoted to crime. Instead, your guide leads you through central Florence, stopping at places tied to executions, prisons, religious conflict, abuse, murder, and old superstition.
The route takes about 90 minutes to two hours. That range matters because the pace can change with questions, group size, and the timing of the tasting stops. You should expect a social walk, not a fast march from one address to another.
The tour is offered in English or Spanish. Guides can vary, with Gabriel, Ilaria, and Ezgi among the names connected with recent departures. The strongest part of the guiding style is its personal touch. Gabriel has been praised for adapting the stories to the group, while Ilaria has a warm, animated manner and often adds local suggestions. That makes this a good pick if you prefer a guide who talks with you rather than simply reciting a script.
More Dark History Tours in Italy
- Venice: Mysterious Tales of Ghosts and Murders
★ 4.9 · 636 reviews - Rome: Guided Bar Crawl with Drinks & Dark History
★ 4.9 · 444 reviews - Rome: Small Group Rome’s Dark Side – Ghosts & Legends Tour
★ 4.9 · 343 reviews
Piazza della Signoria and Savonarola’s fire

The usual opening is beneath the statue of Cosimo I de’ Medici in Piazza della Signoria. This is one of Florence’s grandest public squares, but the tour asks you to see it as a stage for punishment and power.
Here you hear about Girolamo Savonarola, the Dominican friar who attacked Florence’s luxury and moral excess. His sermons helped create a feverish atmosphere in the city, and his campaign against vice became tied to the famous Bonfire of the Vanities. His story ended in execution by hanging and burning in the same square.
The value of this stop is the setting. You are not hearing about Savonarola in a distant lecture hall. You are standing where crowds once gathered and where religious conviction, political rivalry, and public punishment met. The tale also gives you a useful key to Florence: beauty and brutality were never far apart.
This opening may be intense for some people, especially if you are hoping for a light introduction to Florence. It is also a strong choice for returning visitors who already know the Duomo and Uffizi and want a different way into the city.
Via dei Calzaiuoli and the quieter passages

From the square, the group moves along Via dei Calzaiuoli, a central route connecting Piazza della Signoria with the Duomo. The walk then turns toward the narrower Vicolo dei Lavatoi.
The contrast is part of the fun. Florence’s main streets are full of movement and grand architecture, while a small passage can suddenly feel private and enclosed. Here the stories shift toward penance, obsession, and old beliefs that cling to overlooked corners.
The tour also refers to the Mugnone, known in folklore as the River of Corpses. The stream is tied to stories of drownings, disappearances, and occult activity. You should treat these elements as folklore and local legend rather than a straight historical account. That blend is exactly what gives the tour its mood, but it also means the experience moves between documented crime and tales passed down over time.
The guide’s storytelling matters most here. A flat delivery could make these legends feel like filler. The feedback about Gabriel, Ilaria, and Ezgi points to guides who bring humor, warmth, and energy to the walk, which helps the darker material stay entertaining rather than heavy.
A Tuscan tasting near the Duomo

The first food stop is at Crudi e Bollicine in the San Lorenzo area, with the tasting listed at about 15 minutes. You can expect Tuscan wine and a board of local specialties, including cold cuts. Vegetarian choices are available, which is important if you do not eat meat.
This break is more than a snack. It gives you time to sit with the stories and enjoy Florence in a normal, everyday way. A glass of wine beside a plate of regional food keeps the tour from becoming a grim procession.
The food also adds value to the price. At $34 per person, you are paying for a guided central Florence walk plus two tasting moments. That is a fair proposition if you would otherwise book a separate food tasting or wine stop. It is less compelling if you are mainly shopping for a serious history tour and do not care about the food.
The tasting is not described as a full meal. Have a proper meal before or after if you are hungry. Think of this as a generous pause with local flavors, not dinner.
More Ghost Walking Tours in Italy
- Rome: Paranormal Night Walking Tour & Secret Backstreets
★ 4.9 · 1,921 reviews - Rome: Haunted City Night Walking Tour
★ 4.9 · 616 reviews - Haunted Rome Ghost Night Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 495 reviews - Ghosts, Legends & Mysteries of Rome Tip-Based Walking Tour
★ 4.7 · 284 reviews
Piazza del Duomo and Florence’s darker undercurrent
The route reaches Piazza del Duomo for another guided section of about 15 minutes. This is where most people expect polished architecture, photographs, and the familiar Florence story. Your guide adds a less comfortable layer.
The stop helps connect the city’s grand public image with the crimes and fears that existed around it. The tour’s central idea is that the same streets admired for art and architecture were also used for punishment, religious control, imprisonment, and public spectacle.
The Monster of Florence story gives the experience a modern turn. The case began in the late twentieth century and remains unsolved, with the tour focusing on the 1984 mystery. This is likely to interest anyone who enjoys true crime because it moves the discussion beyond Renaissance legends and into a case that still feels unresolved.
Do not expect a forensic investigation or a detailed crime-scene reconstruction. The tour is designed for a broad audience, and its emphasis is the connection between place, story, and atmosphere. If you want every legal detail of the Monster of Florence case, you will need another source. If you want to hear why this story still shadows Florence, the stop makes sense.
Via Ghibellina and the case of Beatrice Cenci

The next major section takes you toward Via Ghibellina and the Bargello area. The Bargello began as a palace associated with justice and authority and later became linked with imprisonment and torture.
Here the guide tells the story of Beatrice Cenci, a young woman accused of killing her father. The case is remembered for its abuse, family conflict, vengeance, and harsh public judgment. It is not a simple murder story. It raises difficult questions about who gets believed, how power shapes justice, and what happens when a victim becomes the accused.
That complexity gives the tour more substance than a string of ghost tales. You hear about people caught inside systems of family power and public punishment. The account may be uncomfortable, so I would not choose this tour for very young children or anyone who wants a completely cheerful evening walk.
The Bargello setting is another strong point. Even if you do not enter the museum, the surrounding streets help you picture Florence’s old justice system as something close, visible, and physical. The guide explains how torture was used not only to punish, but also to frighten others into obedience.
The Stinche prison and the last walk

The route continues along Via del Proconsolo, near the site of the Stinche, once Florence’s most infamous prison. The tour also refers to the Tabernacolo delle Stinche, where condemned people were said to stop and pray before their final walk.
This is one of the most atmospheric sections because it joins a real place with a ritual. A prison tells you how the city confined people. A roadside religious image tells you how the condemned were expected to face death. Together, they show the public side of justice in old Florence.
You should pay close attention to the guide’s explanation here. The tour is not just asking you to admire an old street or imagine a ghost passing by. It is showing how religion, punishment, and civic authority worked together.
The final guided section lasts about 15 minutes before the last tasting. Depending on the exact route and start point, the walk finishes near Piazza di Santa Croce. That makes the ending practical for an evening in the Santa Croce area, though you should check the confirmed meeting and finish points when booking because two starting options are used.
Cantucci, Vin Santo, and a gentler finish
The last tasting takes place at a historic cernacchio, where you try cantucci with Vin Santo. Cantucci are crisp Tuscan almond biscuits, traditionally softened by dipping them into the sweet dessert wine.
After murder cases, prison stories, and executions, this is a welcome change of tone. It also gives the tour a proper Tuscan finish rather than ending with the darkest story of the evening. The food follows the structure of the walk: bitter history, then a small taste of pleasure.
This stop is especially useful if you have not yet tried Vin Santo. It is a classic regional pairing, and the tasting gives you a local food experience without requiring a separate restaurant booking.
Again, this is a tasting, not a full meal. The portions are intended to complement the tour. If you are booking an evening departure, plan your dinner around it rather than treating the food stops as a replacement for dinner.
Is $34 a fair price?

At $34, the tour offers good value for someone who wants a guided walk and local tastings in one outing. You receive an English or Spanish-speaking guide, a route through several central areas, wine, savory food, vegetarian options, cantucci, and Vin Santo.
The price is strongest if you value storytelling and food equally. A basic walking tour may cost less, but it will not include the tastings. A dedicated food tour may offer more dishes, but it may not cover Savonarola, the Stinche, Beatrice Cenci, or the Monster of Florence.
The tour is less suitable if you want a museum-level history lesson, a long meal, or a genuinely frightening ghost experience. One participant expected something scarier and found it more fun than frightening. That is a fair description of the balance: dark subject matter, but a friendly and often playful delivery.
Timing, meeting points, and practical details
There are two possible starting points: Piazza della Signoria or Piazza di Madonna degli Aldobrandini, 6. Your meeting point depends on the option you book, so check it carefully before setting out.
The tour ends with two possible drop-off locations, including Piazza di Santa Croce. Since the route crosses busy central streets, wear comfortable shoes and allow enough time to arrive at the correct starting point.
The walk lasts between 90 minutes and two hours. The listed starting times vary, so availability needs to be checked for your date. Cancellation is free up to 24 hours before the tour, and you can reserve now while paying later, which helps if your Florence schedule is still shifting.
The group has been described as small in at least one experience, but a fixed group size is not provided. Do not assume every departure will have the same number of people.
Who should book this Florence tour?
I would choose this experience if you have already seen Florence’s famous art and want stories that explain how people lived with fear, punishment, belief, and scandal. It also suits solo visitors. Ilaria has been praised for making a solo participant feel welcome, and the food stops create easy moments for conversation.
It is a good match for:
- Adults who enjoy true crime, legends, and unusual city history
- Couples looking for an evening activity beyond a standard monument tour
- Repeat visitors who want a fresh route through central Florence
- Food lovers who want wine and Tuscan specialties built into the walk
- Small groups who prefer a guide with room for questions and local tips
I would be more cautious about booking it for children, people who dislike murder stories, or anyone expecting a horror attraction. The material includes executions, torture, abuse, and unsolved killings. The guides may keep the mood lively, but the subjects remain serious.
Should you book it?
Book it if you want Florence with its polished surface removed for an evening. The route offers real places, memorable stories, and enough food and wine to keep the experience from becoming grim.
The best reason to go is the balance. You get Savonarola and the Stinche, but also prosciutto, Tuscan wine, cantucci, and Vin Santo. You get the Monster of Florence, but also a guide who can offer local recommendations and make the walk feel personal.
Skip it if you want a rigorous academic lecture, a full dinner, or a frightening ghost show. For most curious adults, especially first-time visitors who want something beyond the usual Florence circuit, $34 is a sensible price for a lively, unusual introduction to the city’s darker side.
FAQ
How long does the Florence Crimes, Murders & Ghosts Walking Tour last?
The tour lasts between 90 minutes and two hours. The exact duration can vary, so check the available starting time and details for your chosen date.
How much does the tour cost?
The listed price is $34 per person.
What languages are available?
The tour is offered with a live guide in English or Spanish.
Where does the tour begin?
There are two possible starting locations: Piazza della Signoria and Piazza di Madonna degli Aldobrandini, 6. The meeting point depends on the option booked.
Where does the tour finish?
The experience has two possible drop-off locations, including Piazza di Santa Croce in the Santa Croce area.
Are food and drinks included?
Yes. Wine and food tastings are included, with a Tuscan wine and savory tasting stop, followed by cantucci and Vin Santo.
Are vegetarian food options available?
Yes. Vegetarian options are available at the savory tasting stop.
Can I hear about the Monster of Florence?
Yes. The tour includes the unsolved 1984 Monster of Florence case as part of its true-crime storytelling.
Can I cancel for a full refund?
Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. The tour also offers a reserve-now, pay-later option.
Freshly reviewed haunts around Italy
- Milan Dark Ghost Tour on Foot★ 4.5 · 33 reviews
- Bussana: a ghost village saved by art★ 4.5 · 12 reviews
- Florence Haunted Secrets: Echoes of the Dead Exploration Game★ 4.0 · 9 reviews
- Florence Inferno: Dante’s Haunted Exploration Game and Tour★ 4.5 · 33 reviews
- Full-Day Private Ghost Town Bike Tour in Fabriano and Genga★ 5.0 · 24 reviews
- Rome: Guided Haunted Rome Ghost Tour with Dowsing Rods★ 4.8 · 63 reviews
- Rome: Ghosts & Bone Crypts Tours: 2 Tours, 1 Discount Ticket★ 4.9 · 37 reviews
- Rome: Haunted Ghost Tour, Mystery Crimes and Blackmagic★ 4.2 · 43 reviews
Italy Ghost Tours, compared.

Rome: Paranormal Night Walking Tour & Secret Backstreets
Read our review →
Venice Ghost Stories, Legends and Anecdotes Tour
Read our review →
Venice: Ghost Tour to Rialto and San Marco Square
Read our review →
Rome: Guided Bar Crawl with Drinks & Dark History
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in




